Choosing the right assistant or tool for the job
Know when your everyday assistant is enough, when a specialist tool is better, and how to use haystak's rankings to choose.
There are two kinds of AI product:
- All-round assistants (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Copilot): one app for almost everything.
- Specialist AI tools: built for one job, like transcribing meetings, making presentations or editing photos.
Start with an all-rounder. It covers most jobs. Add a specialist tool only when you do one job often and the assistant is clumsy at it.
How to use haystak to choose:
- Our league table ranks the models inside the assistants, scored out of 10. Use the free filter to see what you can use without paying.
- Our tools rankings rank specialist apps by category, like "Meetings and notes" or "Make images".
- Find my AI asks a few questions and suggests a match.
One tip: the top models are often very close. A ranked 4th might suit you better than the 1st if it's free, or built into apps you already use.
General assistant or specialist tool?
| All-round assistant | Specialist tool | |
|---|---|---|
| Examples | ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Copilot | Meeting note-takers, presentation makers, image editors |
| Best for | Writing, explaining, planning, questions, files | One job done really smoothly |
| Pros | One app, very flexible | Built-in workflow, saves clicks, often integrates with other apps |
| Cons | You do more of the setting up | Another subscription, another login |
Rule of thumb: if you do a job weekly or more, and it takes several steps in a general assistant, a specialist tool may be worth it. Examples: recording and summarising meetings, making slide decks, editing lots of photos.
Reading haystak's LLM league table
- Score out of 10: the week's top scores 10, and others are scored relative to it. Scores combine independent tests with blind head-to-head votes.
- Free or paid: whether you can use the model on the company's .
- What it's good for: plain-English strengths such as writing, coding or analysis.
- Retiring soon: models due to be switched off within 90 days.
Differences of a few tenths of a point are small. Choose among the top group based on price, the apps you already use and what each is best at.
Reading the tools rankings
Tools are grouped by job (for example "Write and edit", "Meetings and notes", "Make video"). Each shows rank, whether there's a free version, what it costs and whether it's available in the UK or US. Click a tool for a short description of what it does.
Questions to ask before paying
- Will I use this at least weekly?
- Does my current assistant already do it, maybe with a better request?
- Is there a free plan I can try first?
- Does it work with the apps and devices I already use?
- Can I cancel monthly?
How AI products are put together
Most AI products sit on top of a small number of foundation models from the big labs. An all-round assistant is the lab's own app around its . A specialist tool usually licenses a model (sometimes several) and adds a purpose-built interface, connections to other software, and features like recording, templates or team sharing. When you choose a tool, you're choosing both the underlying model quality and the workflow around it.
How haystak ranks models
Our methodology explains this in full. In short:
- We combine independent results (standardised tests of reasoning, knowledge, coding and more) with blind human preference votes (people comparing anonymous answers side by side).
- The week's top model scores 10/10 and others are scored relative to it, with a small weight for cost.
- We publish a definitive position, but the statistics behind rankings carry uncertainty, especially near the top. Models within a few tenths of a point are effectively tied.
- Free/paid status is checked against each lab's consumer plans.
Benchmarks have known limits: models can be tuned to do well on popular tests, and tests don't always reflect real-world tasks. Blind votes have limits too: they reflect what people prefer, which can favour style over accuracy. Combining both gives a more rounded view than either alone.
How haystak ranks tools
Tool rankings are popularity-based, using signals such as app store ratings and reviews and how widely websites are used, alongside checks of free plans, prices and regional availability. Popularity isn't the same as quality for your needs, so read the descriptions and try free versions.
A decision approach that works
- List your top three jobs for AI (for example: emails, meeting notes, homework help).
- Test your current assistant on each with a good request (lesson 7).
- Only where it falls short, look at the relevant tools category.
- Trial before buying: most tools have a free tier or trial.
- Review after a month: are you actually using it?
Watch-outs
- Subscription creep: several £10 to £20 subscriptions add up quickly.
- Data handling: smaller tools may have weaker privacy practices than the big labs. Check where data is stored and whether it trains on your content, especially for meeting recordings.
- Lock-in: favour tools that let you export your work.
- Chasing the leaderboard: switching every time a new model tops the table rarely pays off for everyday users. Consistency and good requests matter more.
Try this prompt
I mostly want AI to help with [your main jobs]. I use [phone, apps, work software]. My budget is [free / up to £X a month]. Recommend whether I need anything beyond a general assistant, and why.
Replace the [brackets] with your own details
On haystak
Quick check · 1 of 3
When is a specialist AI tool most worth it?
Next step
Make it remember you: custom instructions, memory and projects
Stop repeating yourself by telling your assistant who you are and how you like answers.